Episode 76, Season 4 - Arnold and Tammi Cuyler – In the Dead of the Night

College sweethearts Arnold and Tammi Cuyler are living a quiet life in Windsor, Connecticut with their two children and nephew.

Always available to lend a helping hand is Tammi’s cousin, Chastity West, who cooks, cleans and babysits the kids.

Chastity is also helping herself to eager participant, Arnold, who is having an affair with his wife’s cousin.

The affair leads to an amicable divorce, with Arnold and Chastity continuing their relationship.

Everyone seems to be getting along, under the circumstances, until a brutal and unfathomable home invasion results in a murder that shakes Windsor, Connecticut to its core.

Listen to the episode HERE.

Photo caption (L-R) Tammi Cuyler was known to be a sweet and caring wife and mother to son Jarrell (pictured) and daughter Lindsey (credit: Investigation Discovery/Twisted Love/Cinemaholic); Arnold Cuyler, Tammi's husband, cheated throughout most of their relationship, including with his wife's cousin, Chastity West (credit: LinkedIn); Tammi's much younger cousin, Chastity, would babysit for the Cuylers and help out around the house - including helping herself to Arnold (credit: Investigation Discovery/Twisted Love/Cinemaholic); Tammi was devastated to learn her husband and cousin were having an affair, causing her to eventually divorce Arnold (credit: Investigation Discovery/Twisted Love/Cinemaholic) Jarrell, Arnold and Tammi's son (credit: Legacy.com) Local news coverage of Chastity's murder trial (credit: Newspapers.com)

Transcript*:

*provided transcripts are lightly edited.

Sources: